Ranking · United States
The 20 Best Classic Sandwiches in America, Ranked
The 20 classic sandwiches you must eat in America, ranked: Parkway's oyster po'boy, Katz's pastrami, Langer's #19, and the Korean cheesesteak in Atlanta.
Get more of The Pass in Google

The burger list started fights. This one will start feuds. After years of eating, arguing, and cross-referencing, here is The Pass’s definitive ranking of twenty classic sandwiches. Decided by our Ask the Pass panel, working chefs and industry pros voting dish-first, hype last. Our ranking, our rules.
More from The Pass: the 25 best burgers in America that started the fights, Louisiana’s creative po’boy revolution, and Katz’s and Russ & Daughters on the Lower East Side.
20. White House Subs: White House Special Italian, Atlantic City, NJ

Atlantic City’s sub temple, running since 1946. The White House Special is an Italian sub the way it was meant to be: bread baked fresh all day with a shattering crust, cold cuts stacked an inch thick, provolone, and the house chopped-pepper dressing. No shortcuts, no rebrand, no second-location energy, just the same counter that’s been doing it right for eighty years. The roll is the argument. The roll wins.
19. Fontano’s: Italian beef, Chicago, IL

Chicago’s defining sandwich, done the Little Italy way. Fontano’s, the sub shop that’s been the self-declared “home of Italian sandwiches” since 1960, shaves its slow-roasted beef thin, piles it into a fresh Italian roll, and dunks the whole thing in peppery jus until the bread surrenders. Hot giardiniera on top for crunch and burn. Named the best sandwich shop in America by Zagat in 2012, and the Italian beef is the reason the regulars keep coming back. Order it dipped. Accept the mess.
18. Versailles: Cubano, Miami, FL

The sandwich Miami runs on. At Versailles on Calle Ocho, open since 1971, the Cubano is ham, mojo-marinated roast pork, Swiss, pickles, and mustard, pressed in Cuban bread baked in-house until the crust shatters and the cheese fuses everything into one. It’s the taste of the city’s Cuban exile story, served at a counter where the cafecito never stops. Pressed flat, eaten fast, remembered long.
17. Defonte’s: Nicky Special, Brooklyn, NY

Red Hook’s Italian-American monument. The Nicky Special layers ham, capicola, salami, and provolone with fried eggplant and a hot salad that hits with a vinegar punch, all on bread built to contain the chaos. Defonte’s has been at it since 1922, feeding dockworkers before the neighborhood had a name for what it is now. The sandwich hasn’t changed. It didn’t need to.
16. Schwabl’s: Beef on weck, West Seneca, NY

Buffalo’s other great sandwich, and Anthony Bourdain’s order when he came through town. Schwabl’s, pouring since 1837 and one of America’s oldest restaurants, hand-carves its roast beef to order and serves it on a kummelweck roll crusted with salt and caraway. A smear of fresh horseradish that clears your sinuses, a dip of natural jus, and that’s it. No gimmicks in nearly two centuries. None needed.
15. Bolton’s Spicy Chicken & Fish: Hot chicken sandwich, Nashville, TN

Nashville hot chicken’s indie original. Bolton’s, the independent East Nashville spot at 624 Main St run by the Bolton family since 1997, traces its lineage straight to the source: Bolton Polk cooked at Prince’s in the 1970s before the family opened its own shop. The hot chicken sandwich is cayenne-crusted fried chicken on white bread with pickles, the way the dish was built to be eaten, heat first, cooling crunch after. Bourdain brought Parts Unknown here; the Southern Foodways Alliance named it a Nashville Food Heritage Site. One of the city’s oldest Black-owned hot chicken spots, and still doing it the old way.
14. John’s Roast Pork: Roast pork Italiano, Philadelphia, PA

Philadelphia’s other sandwich, and the one the city’s chefs would save in a fire. John’s slow-roasts its pork until it gives, then piles it with sharp provolone and bitter broccoli rabe on a seeded roll: pork fat, sharp cheese, bitter greens, chewy bread, in that order. A James Beard America’s Classic since 2006, running out of a South Philly corner since 1930. The cheesesteak gets the tourists. This gets the locals.
13. Angelo’s: Cheesesteak, Philadelphia, PA

The line starts before the doors open, and it’s for the cheesesteak. Angelo’s Pizzeria, the takeout-only South Philly shop at 736 S 9th St, builds its cheesesteak on a house-baked seeded roll: thin-sliced ribeye, fried onions, and a blanket of melted Cooper Sharp, the creamy Philly-made cheese the purists swear by. Cash only, Wednesday through Sunday, and worth every minute of the wait. The pizza is excellent. The cheesesteak is the legend.
12. Langer’s: #19 pastrami, Los Angeles, CA

The West Coast’s answer to the deli canon, and it doesn’t do deference. Langer’s #19 is thick-cut pastrami, steamed until it surrenders, with molten Swiss, cold slaw, and Russian dressing fused into twice-baked rye, the double bake giving the bread the structure to hold the whole steaming pile. A MacArthur Park institution since 1947. Katz’s is the temple; this is the argument that the faith traveled well.
11. Eventide Oyster Co.: Brown butter lobster roll, Portland, ME

Warm lobster, brown butter, a steamed bao-style bun: the lobster roll that broke the rules and got away with it. Eventide’s famed brown butter lobster roll folds sweet Maine lobster through nutty brown butter vinaigrette and stuffs it into a pillow-soft steamed bun, finished with chives. It’s the signature of the 86 Middle Street original in Portland’s Old Port, the oyster bar that set out to revive the great American oyster bar and ended up making the country’s most imitated lobster roll. Rich, warm, and nothing like the cold mayo rolls up the coast.
10. R&O’s: Roast beef po’boy, Metairie, LA

The roast beef po’boy is New Orleans’ great debate, and R&O’s is where the traditionalists land. Slow-roasted beef, sliced thin, piled onto crisp French bread and drowned in debris gravy, the kind of sandwich that requires a strategy and a stack of napkins. Metairie locals treat it as a birthright. They’re right.
9. Deli Board: The Carzle, San Francisco, CA

At Deli Board in SoMa, more is more, one protein in your sandwich? Cute. The Carzle is the pastrami-brisket heavy hitter: paper-thin Romanian pastrami piled with rich, tender brisket in a well-stuffed French roll, slathered in Board sauce with pepperoncini heat cutting through. It’s meaty, it’s rich as hell, and it won’t disappoint. Order at the walk-up counter, take the golf ball-sized pickle juice bombs on the side, and plan to be full for nine hours.
8. Joe’s Kansas City: The Z-Man, Kansas City, KS

Barbecue between bread shouldn’t work this well. The Z-Man layers slow-smoked brisket with melted provolone and a tangle of crispy onion rings on a toasted kaiser roll, smoke, fat, crunch, and tang in every bite. It’s the sandwich that turned a gas station barbecue joint into a national pilgrimage site. Plan around the line.
7. Fred’s Meat & Bread: Korean Cheesesteak, Atlanta, GA

The best cheesesteak in Atlanta doesn’t come from a Philly transplant, it comes from a Korean-leaning sandwich shop in Krog Street Market. Fred’s Korean Cheesesteak starts with chopped ribeye seared on the flattop, draped in American cheese, then hit with gochujang sauce, spicy candied jalapeños, garlic aioli, and green onions on a sesame roll. Sweet, heat, funk, and beef, the remix that converts purists. The Michelin Guide agreed: this is a Bib Gourmand shop, and this is the sandwich to order.
6. Cali Sandwich Co: Combination banh mi, Houston, TX

Houston’s banh mi game is the best in America outside Vietnam, and Cali Sandwich Co in Midtown is the landmark. The combination, the Cali combo, layers cold cuts and rich pâté with pickled daikon and carrot, cucumber, jalapeño, and cilantro on a crackly baguette that’s shattering at the crust and pillowy inside. Tang, funk, heat, crunch, the best value sandwich in the country, and it’s not particularly close.
5. Turkey and the Wolf: Bologna sandwich, New Orleans, LA

A bologna sandwich has no business being this good. Turkey and the Wolf, Bon Appétit’s Best New Restaurant in 2017, takes the humblest cold cut in the American canon and treats it like foie gras: thick-cut, seared, stacked with the works. It’s funny until you taste it. Then it’s just the standard by which all ironic-gourmet sandwiches get judged.
4. Cochon Butcher: Muffuletta, New Orleans, LA

This is the muffuletta the city’s chefs eat. Cochon Butcher, Donald Link’s Warehouse District butcher shop, builds it with house-cured capicola, mortadella, and salami, layered thick with provolone on a 5-inch Gendusa’s sesame roll, each half slicked with house giardiniera: cauliflower, carrots, green olives, pepperoncini. The original was invented in 1906 for Sicilian dock workers; this is what that century-old idea tastes like when it gets the full charcuterie treatment.
3. Dalessandro’s: Cheesesteak, Philadelphia, PA

Philadelphia’s cheesesteak war has two famous combatants, and the connoisseurs’ money is on the Roxborough corner shop. Dalessandro’s chops its ribeye fine on the flattop, melts the cheese through the meat instead of on top of it, and packs it into a roll that holds. No gimmicks, no whiz debate required, just the most technically sound cheesesteak in the city that invented it.
2. Katz’s Delicatessen: Corned beef & pastrami, New York, NY

Since 1888, the temple. The move is the custom combo: corned beef and pastrami together, with Russian dressing, kraut, and mustard, on rye that exists mainly as a delivery system. The meat is the argument, pepper-crusted, hand-cut, steaming, and nearly a century and a half in, nobody has improved on it. Take the ticket, tip your cutter, find a table, be quiet for a while.
1. Parkway Bakery & Tavern: Oyster po’boy, New Orleans, LA

A century-old corner tavern, a basket of Gulf oysters fried to order, and the best fried-seafood sandwich on earth. The Parkway oyster po’boy is the platonic ideal: shatteringly crisp oysters, fully dressed with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and mayo on Leidenheimer French bread, the sweet, crackling loaf that makes every New Orleans po’boy possible and no other city’s sandwich quite the same. This is the one we’d cross the country for. This is the one we did.
What did we get wrong?
That’s the question we ask after every ranking, and we mean it. The sandwich canon is personal, your hometown deli, your gas-station po’boy, the Cuban your grandfather swore by. Tell us in the comments on Instagram: what did we miss, and what did we get wrong?
Like this story?
Get The Pass in your inbox every Friday, free.
Questions, answered
What is the best sandwich in America?
Our #1 is the fried oyster po'boy at Parkway Bakery & Tavern in New Orleans: golden cornmeal-fried Gulf oysters piled on dressed Leidenheimer French bread. Behind it, Katz's pastrami on rye (#2) and Langer's pastrami (#3).
What is the best po'boy in New Orleans?
Parkway Bakery & Tavern's fried oyster po'boy tops our national ranking. Order it dressed with extra pickles, and get there before the lunch line builds.
Where can I get the best pastrami sandwich?
Katz's Delicatessen on the Lower East Side (#2) for the classic hand-carved pastrami on rye, or Langer's in Los Angeles (#3) for the peppery double-baked rye version.
What is the best cheesesteak in Philadelphia?
Angelo's Pizzeria makes our top-ranked cheesesteak: shaved ribeye, cooper sharp, and a seeded roll baked in-house.